Benny's American Burger Milton Menu
Benny's American Burger Milton menu gallery
Choose your favorite dish
Beef Burger ????
Angus beef patty, American Cheese, Burger sauce, Onion & Pickles
Angus beef patty, American Cheese, Burger sauce, Onion, Pickles, Tomato & Lettuce
Double Angus beef patty, Double cheese, BBQ sauce, Onion & Pickle
Angus beef patty, American Cheese, Hot sauce, Onion, Jalapeno & Lettuce
Angus beef patty, Bacon, Egg, Cheese, BBQ sauce, Onion, Tomato, Beetroot & Lettuce
Angus beef patty, Bacon, Chips, Curd cheese, Gravy, Mustard mayonnaise & Onion ring
Angus beef patty, Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Cheese & BBQ sauce
Angus beef patty, Cheese, BBQ sauce, Caramelized onion & Slaw
Chicken Burger ????
Chicken patty, Mayonnaise, BBQ sauce, Pickle & Lettuce. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Chicken patty, Mayonnaise, BBQ sauce & Slaw. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Chicken patty, Cheese, Hot sauce, Onion, Jalapeno & Lettuce. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Chicken patty, Bacon, Mayonnaise, Onion, Tomato, Avocado & Lettuce. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Nashville glazed chicken patty, Cheese, Ranch, Pickle & Slaw. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Chicken patty, Ham, Bacon, Cheese, Mayonnaise, Pineapple & Lettuce. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Crispy chicken patty, Bacon, Cheese, Ranch, Hot sauce, Jalapeno & Lettuce. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Chicken patty drowned in buffalo sauce, Benny's sauce, Cheese & lettuce. Made from chicken breast marinated in the batter.
Premium Burger
Eight hours slow-cooked pulled pork, Cheese, BBQ sauce, Aioli, Jalapeno & Slaw
Angus beef patty, Chicken patty, Eight hours slow-cooked pulled pork, Bacon, Double cheese, Hash brown & BBQ sauce.
Angus beef patty, Crispy chicken tenders, Eight hours slow-cooked pulled pork, Bacon, Double Cheese, Ranch, Tomato sauce, Caramelized onion, Tomato & Lettuce.
Angus beef patty, Eight hours slow-cooked brisket, Double cheese, BBQ sauce & Onion.
Eight hours slow-cooked pulled beef brisket, Cheese, BBQ sauce, Aioli, Jalapeno & Slaw
Veggie&Vegan Burger
Veggie patty, Cheese, Aioli, Tomato sauce, Onion ring, Tomato, Jalapeno & lettuce.
Veggie patty, Cheese, Habanero mayonnaise, Onion, Tomato, Jalapeno & Lettuce.
Veef patty, Cheese, Aioli, Onion, Tomato, Avocado & Lettuce.
Veef patty, Cheese, Tomato Sauce, Mustard, Onion, Pickle, Tomato & Lettuce.
Veef patty, Cheese, Hot sauce, Onion, Jalapeno & Lettuce.
Poutines
Chips Topped with Curd Cheese & Gravy
Chips Topped with Curd Cheese, Bacon & Gravy
Chips Topped with Curd Cheese, Chicken & Gravy
Chips Topped with Curd Cheese, Eight hours slow-cooked pulled pork & Gravy
Chips Topped with Curd Cheese, Eight hours slow-cooked pulled beef brisket & Gravy.
Sides ????
Chicken Sides ????
Kids Meal ????
Beef patty, American cheese and tomato sauce. Served with a little portion of chips.
Double chicken tenders, Cheese & Mayonnaise. Served with a little portion of chips.
Five pieces of chicken nuggets. Served with a little portion of chips.
Beverages ????
From a reviewer’s perspective, the menu at Benny's American Burger Milton presents a broad, indulgent range of American-style comfort food that leans heavily into burgers, loaded sides, and hearty extras. The Beef Burger section covers the essentials with options like Cheeseburger, Standard Beef Burger, Benny’s Double Beef Burger, Spicy Beef Burger, and Aussie Burger, offering both classic and more robust, flavour-packed variations. The Chicken Burger lineup is equally diverse, featuring Classic Chicken Burger, Henny Chicken Burger, Spicy Chicken Burger, along with standout specialty options such as Avocado Chicken Burger and Nashville Chicken Burger.
For those seeking more indulgent or creative builds, the Premium Burger section stands out with richer, heavier choices like Pulled Pork Burger, The Iron Lotus Burger, Bigger Than Texas Burger, Fat Boy Burger, and Brisket Burger, all clearly designed for big appetites and bold flavours. Vegetarians and vegans are also well catered for in the Veggie & Vegan Burger range, including Classic Veggie Burger, Spicy Veggie Burger, Simple Vegan Burger (VG), Vego Cheese Burger (VG), and Hot Vegan Burger (VG), ensuring plant-based diners still get variety and heat.
Beyond burgers, the menu extends into comfort-food sides and shareables. The Poutines selection is especially notable, with Traditional Poutine, Bacon Poutine, Chicken Poutine, Pulled Pork Poutine, and Brisket Poutine, reinforcing the venue’s rich, decadent theme. Supporting items include Chips, Tater Tots, Mac and Cheese, Chicken Nuggets, and Sweet Potato Chips, while the Chicken Sides such as Chicken Wings and Chicken Tenders add more snacking or sharing options.
For younger diners, the Kids Meal options like Simple Beef Burger, Simple Chicken Burger, and Munch Box keep things straightforward. Finally, the Beverages list-Thickshake, Soft Drinks, and Orange Juice-rounds out a classic burger-joint experience. Overall, the menu reads as expansive, indulgent, and clearly focused on comfort-driven American diner favourites with something for most appetites.